Case study · POD Ninjas · print-on-demand training
Joe Robert’s challenge sold 200 seats. The one before it sold 100.
This is what was in the box, and why each piece was in there.
$10,000 to start, about $25,000 through design.
The first challenge held after implementing the custom box strategy
The result, in three numbers
-
100 → 200
Seats sold in the 14-day POD Ninja Challenge
-
20% → 40%
Conversion into the $500 backend program
-
4x
Total campaign revenue
Custom Box Agency’s own label on the conversion number, verbatim: “Doubled from 20%, 10% over Joe’s goal on his $500 offer”. All three figures are published on the Custom Box Agency case study.
“Not only did we meet the goal, but this box upleveled my brand and allowed me to charge a premium.”
Joe Robert, POD Ninjas
The first line on Joe Robert’s own website is “No Lamborghinis Here…”
He teaches people to run print-on-demand stores on Shopify. There’s a free course, and there’s private coaching. By his own count his private coaching students have made about $5 million in sales on their own stores, and when one of them hits a milestone he mails them a mug. About a hundred mugs so far.
The front end of that business is a fourteen-day challenge. The back end is a $500 program. Joe wrote down what was wrong with each of them, in four sentences.
Four problems, in his words.
-
Stalled challenge sales
“Despite consistent marketing, sales wouldn’t budge past 100 seats.”
The competition was running virtual-only events. Joe needed a reason to stand out from them.
-
Drop-off and low engagement
“Attendees were losing focus halfway through the Challenge.”
The backend offer was presented on Day 12 of 14. Anyone who checked out on Day 7 never heard it.
-
Backend conversion stuck at 20%
“Only 20% of Challenge participants converted into my $500 program.”
Four out of five people who paid to be in the room didn’t take the next step.
-
No clear picture of what to build
“I had so many ideas, but I needed help defining the ‘big idea’ and execution.”
He had fourteen days of ideas and no order to put them in.
Nobody talked about what to print until the fourteen days were mapped.
Every engagement opens the same way. A two-hour strategy session on where the business is and where it’s trying to get to, then a full-day workshop at the CBA Lab in Austin, or virtual if you can’t get to Texas. Out of it comes the CBA Blueprint, in under two weeks.
For Joe that meant fourteen days, mapped one at a time, with a $500 offer sitting on Day 12.
“The way Mark envisioned the Challenge blew me away!”
Joe Robert
Six pieces. Every one of them has a job.
Envelope artwork, milestone badges and printed guides, all from the Custom Box Agency case study.
-
Welcome note
Does: gets attendees excited to dive in
-
Quick start guide
Does: removes the confusion before it starts
-
Journey map with sticker badges
Does: makes fourteen days of progress physical
-
14 sealed daily challenge envelopes
Does: builds anticipation, and signals the offer
-
14 action cards
Does: turns attention into a finished task
Inside each envelope, a prompt and a worksheet designed to produce a quick win and keep the attendee focused on the experience.
-
Branded pop-up phone holder
Does: puts the brand on their favorite everyday item
A customer favorite box add-in, in Custom Box Agency’s own words. Real utility, and people shared it.
Six here. A typical Custom Box Agency box carries 30 to 50 unique assets, and every one of them has to earn its slot the same way these six did.
The offer arrived on Day 12.
So did a different envelope.
Joe Robert presented his $500 backend program on Day 12 of the fourteen. Envelopes 12, 13 and 14 were printed blue; the eleven before them were not. Journey map and colour scheme: Custom Box Agency.
Day 12
Envelopes 1 through 11 were neutral. Envelopes 12, 13 and 14 were blue.
Joe presented the $500 offer on Day 12. So the last three envelopes were printed bold blue and the eleven before them weren’t.
Nobody announced it. The attendee had been ripping open one envelope a day since Day 1, working through a stack that all looked the same, and on the day the offer arrived the envelope in their hand looked different.
“The color change built excitement as the offer approached.”
Joe Robert
“The envelopes built anticipation and kept attendees focused.”
Joe Robert
Day 1The $500 offer, Day 12
In Joe’s words
What Joe Robert said about the finished box
“It didn’t really hit me until I opened the finished Challenge box for the first time–this really was more than your average box of branded stuff. It was a whole experience. Going through the guides, action cards, and envelopes made me realize just how much my customer experience needed to improve. My attendees’ barriers to success were flying under my radar. CBA helped me not only see the barriers, but help me completely eliminate them for my people.”
Joe Robert, founder, POD Ninjas
Seat sales moved, and nobody was aiming at seat sales.
The work was pointed at the middle of the challenge, where people were checking out, and at Day 12, where the offer had to land. Seat sales sit ahead of both of those, before any box has been opened, and they moved anyway. The challenge had stopped being the same kind of thing to buy.
Joe’s marketing was fine. The fourteen days after it were where the money leaked.
Ad spend would have bought more people entering a challenge that leaked halfway through, and 20% of a bigger number is still 20%. What moved was the part between the purchase and the offer: something to open every day, a map filling up with sticker badges, and on Day 12 an envelope that looked different from the eleven before it.
What it costs
$10,000 to start. About $25,000 through design.
-
Activate
$10,000Under two weeks
Two-hour strategy session plus a full-day workshop, Austin or virtual. Output: the CBA Blueprint, with product overview, content outline, estimated costs, and an ROI forecast.
-
Build
$5,000 / monthTypically two to three months
Dedicated Client Success Manager, print design team, sourcing specialists.
-
Produce
No separate fee publishedVaries by product
Supplier activation, sample sign-off, mass production, assembly and kitting, in-house QC.
-
Deliver
$2,500 / monthOptional, ongoing
Austin warehouse, direct to customer or in bulk.
Hard costs
- Boxes: $15 to $30 each, depending on contents and quantity.
- Domestic shipping: about $15 per box up to five pounds. International: $32.
- Mailers: $2 to $6.
Order sizes and timing
Phases one and two together run approximately $25,000. There’s no minimum order, but 50 or 100 units cost nearly what 250 cost to produce, so 250 is the smallest number worth considering, and 1,000 is where the price breaks get significant. Three to five months from the first session to boxes in the mail.
What Joe spent isn’t published, and nothing on this page is his invoice. The figures above are Custom Box Agency’s published rates, from its contact and process pages.
What part of your customer journey needs a physical anchor?
Joe’s was the fourteen days between the sale and the offer. Yours might be onboarding, or the stretch after someone finishes. Bring the number that stopped moving, and phase one goes to work on it.
Book a discovery call Back to the concept homepage
Goes to the real Custom Box Agency contact page. This concept has no form of its own.